Artificial Intelligence Guidance
To prepare students for the careers of today – and tomorrow — educators must explore and integrate artificial intelligence (AI) into K-12 classrooms.
It’s a technology that’s already making its way to classrooms in the form of adaptive software, recommendation engines, and digital assistants. Generative technologies like ChatGPT, while causing a stir, present an opportunity to transform learning – as long as educators and learners discover how to strike the proper balance of risk vs. benefits.
What AI Is
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is about training computers to think and learn like humans. In the last few years, many AI tools have become available for anyone to use online, often for free. The most popular of these tools is ChatGPT which takes a user prompt and generates various types of content based on the request. For students, AI can help by providing personalized learning experiences, offering extra practice and support, and giving quick feedback on their work. This makes learning easier and more fun, helping students understand subjects better and succeed in their studies.
What AI Is Not
Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a powerful tool, but it’s important to understand its limitations. AI is not the same as human intelligence; it lacks consciousness, emotions, and self-awareness. It can make mistakes and produce biased outcomes, as it relies on the quality of the data and algorithms it uses. AI systems need human oversight and cannot operate independently, especially for important decisions. AI is not meant to replace jobs but to assist with routine tasks, freeing up time for more complex work. Its solutions are often task-specific and may not easily transfer to different situations. Traditional methods can sometimes be more effective, particularly for complex or sensitive issues. AI requires continuous monitoring and updates to stay accurate and relevant, and it should be seen as part of a broader strategy rather than a standalone solution.
AI isn’t perfect
Results are based on the information the AI was programmed with or has access to. These sources were created by people and may reflect their biases or be inaccurate.
The Five Big Ideas in Artificial Intelligence
1. Perception
Computers perceive the world using sensors. Making computers “see” and “hear” well enough for practical use is one of the most significant achievements of AI to date.
2. Representation and Reasoning
AI agents maintain representations of the world and use them for reasoning. Computers construct representations using data structures, and these representations support reasoning algorithms that derive new information from what is already known. While AI agents can reason about very complex problems, they do not think the way a human does.
3. Learning
Computers can learn from data. Many areas of AI have progressed significantly in recent years thanks to learning algorithms that create new representations. For the approach to succeed, tremendous amounts of data are required. This “training data” must usually be supplied by people, but is sometimes acquired by the machine itself.
4. Natural Interaction
Intelligent agents require many kinds of knowledge to interact naturally with humans. AI agents must be able to converse in human languages, recognize facial expressions and emotions, and draw upon knowledge of culture and social conventions to infer intentions from observed behavior. All of these are difficult problems. Today’s AI systems can use language to a limited extent, but lack the general reasoning and conversational capabilities of even a child.
5. Societal Impact
AI can impact society in both positive and negative ways. AI technologies are changing the ways we work, travel, communicate, and care for each other. But we must be mindful of the harms that can potentially occur. For example, biases in the data used to train the AI system could lead to some people being less well served than others. It is important to discuss the impacts that AI is having on our society and develop criteria for the ethical design and deployment of AI-based systems.
Is it wrong to ask AI to write your essay and turn it in as your own work? Absolutely.
However, banning it at school will not prevent students from using it at home. Teachers should be talking to students about AI and addressing the academic and ethical issues that AI-generated writing produces. Students should learn the difference between using AI as a tool versus using it to plagiarize or cheat.
What Benefits Does AI Have on Student Learning?
Collaboration | AI tools can assist students in group projects by offering new ideas, providing research support, and revealing connections between different pieces of information. |
---|---|
Communication | Students can use generative AI to boost creativity in writing, visual arts, and music by suggesting new ideas or generating content for them to build upon. |
Personalized Content and Review | AI can create personalized study materials, summaries, quizzes, and visual aids, support students (including those with disabilities) in developing tailored resources, and help organize and review content. |
Creating Creativity | Students can use generative AI to boost creativity in writing, visual arts, and music by suggesting new ideas or generating content for them to build upon. |
Tutoring Support | AI can democratize tutoring by providing 24/7 support and enhancing instruction, especially for students facing various obstacles and/or barriers. |
Future and Critical Thinking Skills | Students who understand AI are better equipped for diverse careers, gaining skills in computational thinking, data analysis, and solution evaluation. |
What Benefits Does AI Have for Teachers and Staff?
Collaboration | AI can create personalized study materials, summaries, quizzes, and visual aids, support students (including those with disabilities) in developing tailored resources, and help organize and review content. |
---|---|
Communication | AI tools can assist in drafting and improving communications within the school community, implement chatbots for handling routine inquiries, and offer immediate language translation. |
Resource Compilation | AI can democratize tutoring by providing 24/7 support and enhancing instruction, especially for students facing financial or geographic barriers. |
Diagnostic Assessments | Students who understand AI are better equipped for diverse careers, gaining skills in computational thinking, data analysis, and solution evaluation. |
Enhancement for Differentiation and Professional Development | AI can assist educators by recommending tailored teaching and learning strategies that align with student needs, personalizing professional development to fit teachers' interests and goals, suggesting interdisciplinary or collaborative projects, and providing simulation-based training scenarios like conducting a lesson or managing a parent-teacher conference. Additionally, AI can support educators by suggesting relevant books or articles for lessons and keeping them informed about the latest teaching techniques, research, and methods. |
Risk Mitigation Considerations
Plagiarism | To reduce plagiarism and AI tool misuse, teachers should clarify AI usage guidelines and redesign assignments. Focus on the creation process, require personal insights, and encourage original data collection. |
---|---|
Misinformation | Students should learn to critically assess AI-generated content for misinformation and manipulation, and be educated on the responsible creation and sharing of content. |
Inequitable Access | If an assignment allows the use of AI tools, they should be provided to all students, as some may have access to these resources outside of school. |
Continue Reading about Artificial Intelligence and Education
Additional Resources for Crafting AI Guidance and Policies
- Artificial Intelligence and Future of Teaching and Learning: Insights and Recommendations (United States Dept. of Education, OET)
- Bringing AI to Schools: Tips for School Leaders (ISTE)
- Setting Conditions for Success: Creating Effective Responsible Use Policies for Schools (CoSN, ISTE)
- Guidance for Generative AI in Education and Research (UNESCO)
- The urgent need to update district policies on student use of artificial intelligence in education (PACE)
- From reactive to proactive: Putting districts in the AI driver's seat (PACE)
- Off Task: EdTech Threats to Student Privacy and Equity in the Age of AI (CDT)
AI Literacy and Digital Literacy
- AI 101 for Teachers from Code.org, ETS, ISTE, and Khan Academy
- AI4K12 Five Big Ideas in AI
- ISTE’s AI resources, including ISTE Standards: Computational Thinker (ISTE)
Citing AI Use
Academic Integrity
- Combating Academic Dishonesty from the University of Chicago
- Promoting Academic Integrity in your Course from Cornell University
- Strategies for Teaching Well When Students Have Access to Artificial Intelligence (AI) Generation Tools from George Mason University
Ethical AI Procurement
- Media AI Ratings System (Common Sense Media)
- Emerging Technology Adoption Framework (Digital Promise)
- The Ethical Framework for AI in Education (Institute for Ethical Al in Education)
References
Code.org, CoSN, Digital Promise, European EdTech Alliance, Larimore, J., and PACE (2023). AI Guidance for Schools Toolkit. Retrieved from teachai.org/toolkit. 07/31/2024.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.